Spent the entire day at a conference with lots of smart folks dedicated to promoting a progressive vision for the South. Panels such as: "Mind of the South: Understanding Public Attitudes," "Rethinking Tax Policy," "Belief and Politics: Rethinking the Roles of the Faith Communities," "The Changing Face of the South: Rethinking Culture, Community and Politics." Hallelujah!
Drat. Where to start when after one spends an entire day in the company of
(presumably) like-minded others working toward a coherent progressive
future one wants only to crawl under the bed and lie there in the cool
darkness away from the rest of humanity? It's too important and it's
too dismaying. I left so ambivalent about the whole thing.
But let's start with the positive. Careful thinking, sound policy, a fair reading of the continuing impact/import of race, a willingness to connect and collaborate, a head-on approach to perceived failings of Dem movements, esp. around issues of faith, a decided lack of bitterness (ahem), and, last but not least, sense of humor. These are all good things. We have reasons to celebrate, for sure. But that's not what worries me. I'm never worried that the progressive vision is correct or based on sound policy or centered around a multiplicity of views. It is, undeniably. (Strategies and implementation of those policies can be debated, of course.)
I'm worried that there was not an explicit class analysis, that there was a too-heavy reliance on the example of the Civil Rights Movement as a movement of united faith communities*, that there was no media plan of attack. I wanted a discussion of the structural underpinnings of our battle to win hearts and minds and a Nielsen share. It's no longer "just the facts, ma'am." People have only so much use for facts; they need a philosophy, a worldview, a reason to contribute to the greater good. If the mantra is fear, fear, fear, no one can hear why sound tax policy makes sense for us all. They're too busy buying duct tape and scrimping so their kid can go to private school. What are we doing about this? Duct tape and private school are the symptoms of the Dem malaise. Why have people given up on public education? Why do we think Osama is going to bomb us in our beds? Where are the Dems? Why aren't we talking about equity and education as avenues to safety and success? Hello?
[*God bless the Civil Rights heroes. Of course we should take the lessons of the CR movement -- we'd be idiots not to -- but we're in a different age. We need to look forward, to devise strategies that work for a contemporary movement. People think we've conquered racism (sheesh), that people are in total control of their destinies; that corporations need defending, that the American Dream hasn't vanished. No. Faith is one way to get back to the people, but the church can do more and the people can do more. We would be well served to remember that MLK, Jr. was marching for workers' rights when he was killed in Memphis. He had to be brought around to the idea of marching for labor, and to his credit, he did come around. Class and race are inextricably bound, and maybe the Dems can take a page from John Edwards' popular "Two Americas" idea, for example.]
So why was I so depressed? We're in an overbooked two-day seminar in one of the Carolina Inn's bigger ballrooms, which is filled to capacity. We're talking about these things and acknowledging that we need to move forward. Blah blah blah. Maybe it's because there aren't many young people there; maybe it's because there isn't much actual strategizing going on; maybe it's because we're still getting our sealegs, and I just can't stand to think it. It's patently obvious that we do not have an overarching philosophy and we need one; lots of nice, young and/or old guard foot soldiers is wonderful, but no message and no way to convey it? We've got to get it together, pals. We need to say something and have it stick. We need an updated and savvy class analysis. This is how we bridge otherwise disparate groups with otherwise disparate (-seeming) "values" (e.g. black & white, urban & rural). We need our own version of Newspeak, which would be, you know, the truth. We need polemicists AND a TV news network. And I'm dead serious. I don't want to waste our time quibbling over whether we should have "our own FAUX News." "Our" F0X News wouldn't be F0X News. A partisan view does not necessitate craven disingenuousness and misleading the public. One can advocate for one's position, one can be partisan even, and have one's arguments based in material fact. And, actually, I'm advocating for an independent TV news network, one free from partisan taint. Can somebody please let me have $1 billion? I promise to use it for good.
There's so much more to be said, but I'm going to have to write this stuff down in some more meaningful way and send it to the conference sponsors if only to make myself feel better. I just can't stand the innocent goodness of coming together and everyone saying their piece and all of us feeling good about our multiculturalness and tolerance and high-minded appeals to the greater good while the other side loots the treasury, sets progress back another century, makes war, ravages the environment, puts forth a policy of deregulation above all, and does very real injury to the idea (and ideals) of democracy. It's heartbreaking. We have got to stop reassuring ourselves for our correctness and goodness and start strategizing and acting on a real vision of progressive values. Sigh.
So I spent the entire evening in a funk until db started intoning into his
beer bottle in a faux-James Earl Jones voice, "Dingo, I am your
faaathaa!" Ha.